Hi K.,
You're her mother. When do YOU think she should have her ears pierced? That would be my first question to you.
But since you're taking a poll, my feelings are this. I have two young daughters. I want some negotiating power when they enter their teen years. Sure they would look adorable now with little diamond studs, but when it comes to asking for tattoos at the age of 9, I will be able to say, "No, sweetheart darling :) but in a few years you can have your ears pierced." And then they'll ask again about that tattoo. :)
I guess for me since I was 13 that was the magical number for me. Even if it's 12 that would be okay too. We all grow up so differently and our experiences really mold how we teach our children.
Another feeling for me is that it is their bodies and they have the right to decide whether or not they want a piercing. I was glad to have that decision at 13.
We can take polls from here to eternity. I do the same thing. It helps me to gather input. But I think for me what really helps after all the poll taking, I need to look deep inside and get quiet and still. Sometimes that means taking out a pen and paper and write. Just write. Not even thinking, but just writing. And whatever the answer is, it will come.
Please let me know how it turns out for you. Whatever you decide, I'm sure you'll be fine.
Good luck!
S. "The Shower Diva"
TheShowerDiva.com
Where Fun Reigns!™