T.W.
Here's 2 options. Bath and Body works always has little cute gifts for under $10. Everyone loves stuff from there especially young girls.
Option 2: Go to blockbuster get their bucket of popcorn and then put these things inside, a soda, box of Mike and Ike's or Hot Tamales, a candy bar or two and a gift card for $5 or $10. Stuff some colored tissue paper around and in between the contents. Then she has a movie night all in a nice neat bucket. These both have always been a big hit. Makes good birthday gifts for kids to take to parties too.
Good Luck,
Tiff