A.H.
I don't have any personal experience but I have been reading up on both of these items because I will be purchasing the Innotab for my 3yr old. From what I have read, the Innotab is a much better deal and has a lot more options such as being able to download movies and music. The discs that you buy for them have 3 games vs the LeapFrog only having one per book. At Toys R Us right now, the Innotab is on sale for $79.99 and it includes the carrying case.