Thanks for the Barbie shoe idea!
We just lost our first tooth! We left the tooth in a glass of water on the kitchen table. The fairy took the tooth, colored the water (with food coloring) and sprinkled everything with fairy dust. She even doused my daughter while she was sleeping. She was so proud to be sparkling at school. The fairy left a note, a new toothbrush and paste, a book and a couple dollars. My daughter lives at her father's house too. She knows the fairy does something different each time so we are going to experiment leaving the teeth on the table, under the pillow, etc. Sometimes she'll get something special such as a lip gloss or nail polish , sometimes just a couple coins. The fairy dust is a must! We also left the fairy tea and cookies on a pretty plate.
The Easter Bunny shed pieces of his tail from the front door to the baskets one year. My daughter collected the cotton 3 years ago and still saves it (she's 5 now).
This year the Easter Bunny called my girl. She is still upset we didn't ask him for his phone number.
My all time favorite is something my aunt did for her girl. You know Rudolph the Red-Nosed Reindeer and the Land of Misfit Toys? Every year Santa leaves a broken toy for my daughter because he knows she will still love and appreciate it. One year it was a stuffed animal with a hole in it's seam. Another year it was a Barbie cruise ship with missing pieces. This year will be a discolored Webkinz. Yard sales are a great source for these items.
Glad to know there are other crazy moms out there...I sometimes get very weird looks!