Sounds like a reaction to something in the lotion to me. Did you compare the ingredients list for the two sunscreens? I would. See what is different in the lotion you used on your face, and maybe avoid any sunscreens with that in it in the future...
FWIW, I have started just using "Face Potion" or whatever it is called not just on my face, but everwhere. It is zinc oxide, so it is a physical block, not chemical, and doesn't make free radicals when exposed to sunlight (the newest worry with all the sunscreens out there). And it's cheap, too. Like $2.50 for a little pot of it at Walmart. The little pot things last a long time. And it works.