K.H.
I have a great dentist who I've been seeing for years and he recommended a periodontist with whom I've had 3 gum surgeries. They are both top-notch. My dentist will always discuss options with me and won't ever prescribe something that's unnecessary. It's a small office and his staff is friendly and professional. Dr. Shaw is in Lincoln Park and Dr. Goodman is in Lakeview, both I know weren't exactly on your list but believe me, it's worth going to see them. Here's the info for both of them:
Dr. Frank Shaw, DDS: ###-###-####
2551 N. Clark St, Suite 500
Dr. Charles Goodman, MS DDS: ###-###-####
2835 N Sheffield Ave, Suite 408
Good luck!