Of all of the places mentioned, I would choose Circle C. They have a very vocal and powerful HOA...super important and that is why the schools in that neighborhood are wonderful. The parks are clean and well maintained. The stores are trendy and convenient. Circle C has a great pool and strong, plentiful moms groups. I feel the houses in Circle C are fairly reasonable. Some are reasonable, but need updating. I think you will be very happy down south. I used to live in The Villages of Shady Hollow, but moved because Brodie Lane sucks (understatement); the HOA sucks; and there is tons of vandalism that nothing is being done about. I now live out in the country south of Shady Hollow. Shady Hollow has a middle school called Bailey that lost half of its population to a new middle school that opened up in Circle C, which allowed students from a less accredited school to join. This made Bailey a less desirable school in my mind. Circle C is your very best bet, especially for resale value. Good luck!