Hi Laura,
Congrats on your pregnancy!
One thing to keep in mind is that midwives either do hospital deliveries, OR they do home births. I talked with many, many clinics and midwives when I was in the process of choosing one, and I never found one that did both. (Of course, if you have a home birth and then you need to be transported to the hospital for some reason, your midwife will go with you!). So, I think a good place to start is to decide which type of birth you want, then choose a midwife.
My pregnancy and birth were wonderful, relaxed affairs. When I hear other people talk about their pregnancies and births, I just cringe: women being scared to do or eat ANYTHING; not being able to eat while in labor; routine episiotomies; fourth degree tearing; I could go on and on....
I never once saw an MD while pregnant. I saw the same midwife for all my prenatal appointments, which were 1 hour long, and my husband was at all but one of them. When I delivered (in a hosptial), an RN assisted my midwife.
I am going to give you two midwife recommendations: one who does hospital births, and one who does home births. Neither are in Bloomington, but they might be good starting points for you. My nurse midwife is Stephanie Johnson, and she does hospital births. She is a Nurse Practitioner and sees clients at the clinic at Woodwinds Hospital. She does deliveries both at Woodwinds and at St John's in St. Paul. When I was seeing Stephanie, she was in a private practice in a different location; now she is in the pool of HealthEast midwives. What this means is that you can see her for all your prenatal visits, but when it comes time to deliver, I *think* you will get whatever midwife is on-call/working. (Please call to confirm.)
I can't say enough good things about Stephanie, and I still see her for well-woman exams:
http://www.healtheast.org/providers/provider.cfm?DocID=31024
The home birth midwife I would like to recommend is Dr. Amy Johnson-Grass. In addition to being a midwife, she also is a Naturopathic Doctor. My family has seen her in her ND capacity, and she is wonderful. She has a clinic in St. Paul, near downtown, off of Grand Ave. The plus to her is that since she is also an ND, she could do your baby's well-child exams, too:
http://www.dramyjohnsongrass.com/midwifery.htm
Lastly, the closest free-standing birth center to the Twin Cities is in Menomonie, WI, which is about 1 hour away, just off of I-94. I seriously considered going there, but in the end decided the distance was too much, considering we were having a winter baby and I was concerned about the roads:
http://www.morningstarbirth.com/
Feel free to contact me if you want any more info or just want to chat. I am passionate about midwifery and natural birthing!