Powder vs Liquid Soy Similac - Any Difference?

We were told that shaking the powdered formula was part of the problem. It creates more bubbles which equals more gas. You can buy a fairly inexpensive formula stirring wand. Just be careful because until you get the hang of using it, it can create quite a mess! Those little things are pretty powerful! Hope this helps.

I tried both, with both of my girls. Oh how I remember it like it was yesterday! The powder worked way better than the pre-mixed. The powder is thinner and more easily passes thru their system. The pre-mix is way to thick, and I found that both spit up more often on that.
I think both my girls had their "issues" (same as yours) resolved after I stuck to the powder-about 5 months old. Tried the Nutramigen too, and was no different than the soy, so we went back. You can also try Colic Calm-found on the internet. Helped the gas TREMENDOUSLY!!
Good luck!!

I think that there is. My fist daughter had trouble with spitting up all of the time. Before I switched her, I tried the pre-made reg formula and it worked like a charm. I really think there is something to the already made formula for kids that have trouble digesting. My second never had a problem with the powder so didn't need to spend the extra money on the pre-made. Oh, and by the time my first was cruising (eight months) I switched back to the powder again and she was fine. Once they are active and moving that helps with digestion.

Sometimes the powder can be more gassy than the liquid regardless if its soy or regular. The important thing to remember is to never shake the bottle to mix it with the water when using formula. That creates more bubbles. Its a little more of a pain, but try to stir the formula gently with a spoon to not get it so shaken up. I would use the powder if possible because 1.)its cheaper and 2.) much easier in the summer then you don't have to keep the bottles cold. Just have some room temp water set in a bottle, buy one of those dispensers for the powder and its a cinch! Good luck!

My daughter is severly allergic to milk, so I have used Similac since she was 3 months old. She had a severe reaction to her very first bottle of milk formula. The powdered formula always worked fine for us, but she spit up a lot too. At four months a lot of spit up is pretty normal.We even used the Go and Grow toddler until she was about 2 since she wouldn't drink regular soy milk for a while. Good luck.

My son (3 months) is a spitter-upper. We go through about 8 bibs and 2-3 outfits a day. However he is gaining weight well and is a "happy" spitter. He also has a milk allergy. We are on Similac Isomil Advance, and thought that buying the premade would decrease the spit-up. It didn't. Although I'm not happy about the constant messes, our ped. says that he will outgrow the spitting up soon and that it's better to wait it out than to keep switching formulas every few days- by the time you find a formula that you think "works", he may have just physically outgrown the spitting up. They usually outgrow it by 7 months....I hope he's right! Good luck!

When our son was on soy we bought the liquid. It seemed a little thicker and kept him more satisfied.

At the time (he is now 9 yrs old) the cheapest place I found the formula is at Toys R Us.

Best wishes.
J.

We had better luck with the liquid similac soy... but our baby was almost exclusively breast fed, so the formula was really only in small amounts while I was at work...

My son had reflux so spitup/ gas were very big parts of our lives. We used powder to try and save money over the liquid. We found that if we premade powder and refrigerated one days worth, he was able to digest it the same as liquid since the bubbles were not there from shaking.

Good Luck