D.E.
Hi, a local dollar type store may have some things you're looking for. The last time we did a pinata the dog gone thing was made with cardboard on the inside and it took me hitting it HARD to open it...we bought it at wall mart. If I do another pinata i will weaken it ahead of time by poking small holes like serrations around it, otherwise it was very frustrating for the kids.
Have fun!!!
D.