D.E.
I have written about this before so sorry to anyone who has heard this. My 2 children were terrible about giving up their pacifiers. We tried cutting them, hiding them, trying to tough it out and what finally worked was the Paci Fairy (we call it the Bai Fairy because they called them that.) You have them gather all the pacifiers and put them in a pretty bag and hang them outside for the Paci Fairy - you tell them the story that the Paci Faory takes old pacifiers from big kids and gives them to new babies. The next morning have another bag hanging there with a surprise for them, a present from the fairy. Then when we were out we woudl point out new babies who got pacifiers from the fairy. This worked really well and it is how we got rid of sippy cups and even toys now. Good luck!