J.S.
I had a very difficult time finding supportive nursing bras also. I tried on bras everywhere. If a store offered a nursing bra, I tried it on... The very best I found were from Anita Maternity. I wore the underwire ones. I know they recommend you not wear them but I did and I didn't have any problems. They do have bras that don't have underwire too. I was able to find them at Von Maur in the Yorktown shopping mall in Lombard. They don't have a huge selection there but you could try them on for size and also order online. (I ordered from thepinkbra.com in the past.) They are not the cheapest bras but they made me feel like a real woman for a year while I was nursing. Hope that helps!