I have a friend who did this too. She looked at all the magazines and decided to go outside the box. She is more chickens and cows. She picked lions, tigers, cheetah print fabrics, zebra print fabrics, all the safari stuff.
It's so uncomfortable to go into her house now. This is so not "her" style. She's down to home, mother nature from the country, she had a cute style before but now it's like she's trying to be someone else.
I suggest you look at those magazines over and over, which pictures do you like each and every time.
For instance. When I get to redo my kitchen I do not have a single doubt that I won't pick solid white cabinets and a dark counter-top, probably the darkest sage green I can get. I love dark sage green. It's always been my favorite color but I didn't know it....everyone always said olive drab green/Marine green was my favorite color but as I came to realize I hated that color I acknowledge that it has too much yellow in it, sage greens are a grey green not a yellow green.
I also know that I don't like frilly cabinet doors. I like a very simple basic minimal trim door style. I want a soft shine but not glossy shine too.
SO I know what "I" like and want. I know that I will get that and love it.
The way I came to make this decision was to go online and visit all sorts of sites where they show kitchen redecorating. I right clicked on every kitchen picture I liked and when I renamed them I labeled them Kitchens I like A then Kitchens I like B and so forth. After the alphabet I did Kitchens I like 1 Kitchens I like 2.......
I had the pictures in a folder in my downloads so they were side by side. Since every picture in the file started with the same letters it was easy to find them if they showed in the whole download file alphabetically.
I looked in this folder a few times and realized almost every single picture had white cabinets. Almost exactly the same door style, almost always the shaker front.
And almost always they had a super dark counter-top. So I had found what "I" liked and wanted.
I did the same thing with bedrooms, bathrooms, living rooms, etc..... I left the study up to hubby because it's his man cave. He has the doors blocked off and the only entrance is through our master bedroom. It's his domain, I don't even go in there. The black light blocking curtains help the room to be very dark. So I don't like it.
Don't give in to the urge to do the neutrals that everyone is doing. Make your home your own. To do this in a way where you can feel more confident try my save a picture way. This way you can start narrowing down what you really want to do. If any picture appeals to you then save it under a name that will put them side by side.
Do this over a week or so, pick one room this time then another room when you sit down later. You don't want to do the same room all at once.
If you do it all in the same day they'll all be the same, you won't get the influence of several different moods, you know what I mean....one day you might feel down in the dumps so you might pick all pictures that are somber. Another day you might be really happy and laughing all day, you might pick all sunshine yellow room decor. Then you might have had an argument with hubby and pick all red decor styles.
Our moods influence our choices. So if you get a wide variety of pictures then go back through them you'll find some that are hideous! You won't believe you ever picked those to begin with. Those you just delete. As you go through and fine tune the choices you should start to see your own themes, likes and dislikes.
I think this is a great way to get to the bottom of it all, to find what we really like and to work our way through other people's and fads and habits so we can truly find what we really really like and want.