I took in a laundry basket full of QUALITY gently used toys which included a V-tech computer, etc and I was offer less than $25 for the whole basket. I walked out.
Once Upon a Child was not much better. We took our $500+ crib there and hubby let them have it at $80 because he did not want to bring it back home. I would have left it in the car and advertised elsewhere.
My daughter is now 14. I took a large bag to Plato's CLoset just last week and they turned me down because the sizes were not 00 and up. My sizes were 10-12 with Abercrombie, etc high quality and gently used clothing.
Now I am not sure what I am going to do with this bag of clothing. Goodwill is looking better everyday. I am usually an advocate of getting the tax benefit and I will probably go that route. I can't see selling a pair of very gently used $50 jeans and skirts for $2.
My personal opinion........lose the headache and donate.