K.F.
Interesting answer from Trilexia B. from Staten Island, NY. Not particularly accurate coming from a New Yorker but interesting.
I would recommend Montclair, Bloomfield, Nutley, or Union. Each has pretty decent schools but my favorite is Montclair which is a friendly child oriented cultured place. There is either a train or bus into "The City" (aka NYC). Montclair has restaurantes, local pools, ice skating rink, movie theaters, live theaters, local paper (The Montclair Times), a hospital (Mountainside Hospital), a college, great public transportation, excellent for walking, churches, historical sites, parks to play in, great schools, beautiful housing, shopping centers, supermarkets but still maintains its charm and warmth. Visit their website to learn even more then before you make the move come on out for a visit. Judge for yourself. Yes my opinion is biased but who better than someone who lives there to tell you just how great it really is.
Bloomfield, Nutley or Union are equally nice but without some of the quaintness of Montclair but still the suburban feel and flavor with transporation into NYC too.