Hi R.,
I have an 11 year old daughter who has the same anxiety issues as your son. We noticed it during her pre-school years. She would cry all the time, before pre-school, then Kindergarten.
Esp. if there was something new, that was the worst.
At times, she would get so stressed out that she would get paralized and not move. We did get her assessed several times and they all said the same thing. She is extremely shy, has high anxiety and needs time to warm up to everything.(They even called it a phobia)
The therapist did give us tips on how to tackle this fear. One that works well for us is at anytime we find her in a new situation, we talk about it a lot. Sometimes 6 months to a year before it happens. she needs tons of time to process any event and get ready for it.
Put her in a situation where she has to meet new people. We have her competing in swim meets where she cries the night before, and during her first two races on the first day. (imagine a girl with googles filled with water hunched over on the blocks) After the first two races she is better, and laughing with her team-mates.
She's a strong swimmmer and she now has goals to swim at college level. She has been swimming for a year and a 1/2, 5 days a week and a meet at least once a month. But even at this level, she still cries or becomes very moody before a competition.(there are still so many stories to tell!)
This is who she is, yet I have found that she is much braver now than she was when she was nine. We are finally sending her away to sleep away camp this summer and she is looking forward to it. We had to make arrangements with another swimmer so she will room with a friend who she is really comfortable with.
My best advice to you is, baby steps.... he'll get it. Don't give in to his fears. Because it sounds like he likes baseball and is good at it! Consistency and repetition is good, it does get better as they mature.
It's always a plus to have a coach who is sensitive to children like ours. We were fortunate to have a wonderful coach who really works with her and has tons of patience.
he goes out of his way to communicate with her and praise her.
This also helped her with her anxiety, and far as she is concerned, her coach walks on water.
Please give him a big hug from me, it's really hard for children with high anxiety to accomplish daily things that many children don't even think about.
Good luck and stay strong,
T. P.