I've done a loan modification. Went to my bank about reducing the payments on my home equity loan. The first time I tried it, the loan officer said, that my best option would be to do a full refy of combining both the first and second mortgages, and paying off some credit cards. It would only cost me $400 but save me $1,000 a month. So we paid it even though we couldn't really afford it. I had been told that the loan was approved and I wouldn't have another payment for 6 weeks. At the 11th hour, the underwriter asked for a second review. The appraiser said 'oops, i messed up', and the loan was denied. I was denied because the value of my house was $30,000 less than needed. Luckily I hadn't gone out and blown all of the money that I now had 2 days to come up with! I waited a few months, went back to them and asked for just a modification of the 2nd mortgage. The were hesitant, but finally, as the bank was closing that day (literally!), they approved the loan, and reduced my payment. The mod was for the same interest rate, they just took the remaining amount and spread it back out over 30y. I watch the account like a hawk to make sure that the payment is being credited and the balance is being reduced.
My neighbor did a refy with Ocquin (sp?) and was told that her money would go into a good faith account for the first 3 months, then that would be applied to her balance, and the loan would be good for the terms agreed. Almost as soon as she sent the first payment, they said that the paperwork was wrong and she wasn't paying the correct amount. It also turns out, through their error or hers - not sure, the money she has been sending for the last year was still being applied to the 'good faith' account instead of the true loan account. Now they are telling her that she has to come up with THOUSANDS of dollars or they'll forclose.
There are good loan modifications out there. However, once you do sign a loan mod, WATCH YOUR PAPERWORK!! As soon as you see that something isn't right, or that your principle amount isn't changing, contact them.
M.