LASIK Vs PRK

Updated on February 10, 2011
S.O. asks from Sturgis, SD
5 answers

So, I was just screened for corrective eye surgery and found out that I am NOT a candidate for LASIK, but am for PRK. My husband just had LASIK done last month so I've seen just how easy the recovery (even with one minor complication) has been for him. Now I find out that I cannot have LASIK (my cornea's are too thin) so if I want the surgery, I have to do the PRK version. The end result is the same, but the recovery process is longer and more painful than with LASIK. Needless to say I'm scared and my husband isn't very sympathetic about it. Has anyone out there had PRK and can give me some insight to the recovery length and pain levels? Also, my DS will be 1 year old when I have this done so I will be out of commission to help with him due to the perscription drugs that I will take for pain following the procedure.

What can I do next?

  • Add yourAnswer own comment
  • Ask your own question Add Question
  • Join the Mamapedia community Mamapedia
  • as inappropriate
  • this with your friends

More Answers

Smallavatar-fefd015f3e6a23a79637b7ec8e9ddaa6

J.P.

answers from Chicago on

I had PRK a few years ago for the same reason. I had no children at the time, had about 5 days to recover before going back to work. Even after those 5 days, although the pain was gone, my vision was very fuzzy. I could see well enough to drive, but anything close up was next to impossible for another week. It was very hard to read anything; I had to ask for help several times a day. It was super painful for a few days afterwards. Much of the time, I couldn't really open my eyes because they hurt too much so I was resting with them closed. They will provide you with drops for lubrication and pain, but you might also need Tylenol or some pain reliever. I don't know if you've scheduled this yet, it sounds like you have, but with a toddler around, you should plan to have extra help for at least the first few days. You really won't be up to watching him! Good luck, and pm me if you have other questions!

1 mom found this helpful
Smallavatar-fefd015f3e6a23a79637b7ec8e9ddaa6

C.L.

answers from Minneapolis on

My husband recently had the PRK procedure. He had one eye done in August and one in September. He was not a candidate for Lasik either. Contrary to what you and the other posters have said, it was his understanding the PRK was much less invasive than Lasik and the recovery was actually easier. My husband's doctor is very experienced and well respected in this area of surgery. My husband did very well with it, although you will definitely be out of commission for at least the full day of surgery. He thought the first eye was a piece of cake. The second eye was more painful and although he doesn't usually swear much he was using some colorful language on the ride home after the second eye. He was pretty out of it though and doesn't even really remember that. For both procedures he pretty much slept the rest of the day, but he was back at work the next day. He definitely had discomfort with the second eye for a few days, but nothing unbearable. If you have any specific questions for him feel free to send us a private email and he can get back to you, although it wouldn't be until much later this evening. He had put off the procedure for years because it terrified him, but he was ultimately left with little choice because he had essentially damaged his corneas from years of contact overuse and he was legally blind without contacts or glasses. His vision isn't perfect, but he can now drive and watch TV without glasses. You should probably line up help for your toddler for a couple of days after the procedure, but if it is anything like my husband's experience you should be back to a fairly normal schedule soon. FYI--I don't know your doctor's policy, but my husband's doctor refuses to do both eyes at the same time. That four week interval between eyes was a little inconvenient for him, but the doctor insists upon that protocol.

Edited to add: I asked my husband for his comments. They were more about the long term success of the procedure than the immediate recovery and discomfort. He also didn't know that you weren't a candidate for Lasik. His doctor told him that PRK has fewer complications, but Lasik usually has a more dramatic effect on your vision. Also, your vision continues to change over the course of weeks and months so you won't know your ultimate result immediately. Here are his exact words: "...she should go in with eyes wide open, so to speak. PRK does not provide the precision that traditional Lasik does, so if she is looking to come out of the procedure with immediate 20/15 vision, she should do Lasik. For example, in my case, PRK took me to 20/30, starting from the equivalent of about 20/800+. PRK is also less invasive, so there is less potential for downside."

1 mom found this helpful
Smallavatar-fefd015f3e6a23a79637b7ec8e9ddaa6

C.D.

answers from Milwaukee on

My husband had PRK for the same reason back in 2008. The procedure went fine and recovery still seemed fast (about 3 days). He has very sensitive to light and things were a little fuzzy on day 2-3 but he was still able to function and help out with our son. I did all the driving though. He highly recommends the procedure.

1 mom found this helpful
Smallavatar-fefd015f3e6a23a79637b7ec8e9ddaa6

K.G.

answers from Rochester on

I just had PRK done last year (January '10). The procedure takes just a few minutes and doesn't hurt or anything, but my recovery did take about 3 days. The first 24 hours were painful but it gradually improved. My eyes felt scratchy and I was very sensitive to light for about 48 hours. I had it done Friday and by Monday I could drive myself to work and get back to regular things. My vision was not yet 20/20, but by the time I went in for the 7 day checkup, it was 20/20 when using the eye cover with the holes in it. It may have been another week before I was 20/20 all the time. I just had my one year checkup and am still 20/20. I do remember there was one set of eye drops I had to keep using for 3 months. I also took a trip in February and since it had been exactly 30 days I was allowed to go in the pool again. So there are certain things that you do have to do for up to 3 months that you wouldn't have to do with LASIK, but it's not that bad. If you have your husband home over the weekend, do it on a Friday and you should be ok.

1 mom found this helpful
Smallavatar-fefd015f3e6a23a79637b7ec8e9ddaa6

J.L.

answers from Chicago on

I've heard the same thing...My sister is a PRK candidate not Lasik. As much as I'd like to not have to wear contacts/glasses why risk it???? Yikes, I only get one set of eyes and I'd rather have to wear glasses then risk the pain and complications that may come with PRK.

For Updates and Special Promotions
Follow Us

Related Questions