O.H.
I've been in insurance my whole adult life and owned an independent agency for many years.
You don't need to be as concerned about the company that insures you as you do with your coverage's. You can't compare your rates with anyone else because it's based on many factors such as your age, address, credit, driving record, car and coverage's.
Most people don't "like" to pay for insurance because frankly, most insurance isn't used. However, I always told my clients, the LAST thing you want to be worried about while sitting in the middle of an accident is...what's my insurance going to cover???!!!!! It's WAY too late by then.
A couple things to keep in mind is that the lower your deductible, the higher your premium. Also, don't skip the Rental Reimbursement. If your car is in an accident, don't just assume it will be in the shop a couple days. I was in an accident and the dealer had my mini van for FORTY FIVE days and that was with them looking at my back window that had all my agency info on it...knowing I could bad mouth their service if I wished because of my position. Anyway, I had a car rental that was paid the whole time. Had I not, I'd have been in trouble. And your liability should be enough to cover you if someone were to sue you for all your worth. INCLUDING future income. So if you are 28 and cause permanent damage to someone (like paralyzed) and they get a settlement, they can get part of your pay for as long as you live. No joke. So don't mess around when you've got something to lose, and we all do.
No one ever thinks anything will happen to them. I'm sure all the people in the accidents we see didn't know they'd be in an accident that day. So don't skimp on your insurance and only pay for minimal coverage...it won't help you if you need it. Talk to an independent agent in your area. They have a computer system where they type in all your info once and it goes out to 10+ companies and compares the same info with each one to see who has the best rate. Do this every few years as rates are cyclical. Good luck.