We shop around for insurance thru an agency - around 16 A+rate insurance compnay - farmers, travelers, allstate, countrywide etc) . I am also the broker dealer of the firm and can help you get the good rate. I ahev had three accidents in past no issues - most ofthe claims were settled amicable and cleanly for me personally.
YOu will be getting insurance thru these companies and you dont have to pay to me anything. Generally speaking an insurance is a factor of - Demographics, credit history and driving history. And each of these company have a sweet spot - their ideal market, you will not know which company suits your profile. With so many company under umbrella, there is a greater chance of you coming in that sweet spot of a the company hence get a best rate.
If you feel like giving it s shout out - send me a private message, we will need the declaration page to get comparable rates.
Good luck with your search!!