J.S.
My husband's wedding ring is from James Avery and sounds like something that you and your husband would like. This is the one that he has and we both love it.
http://secure.jamesavery.com/jewelry/search/product/WB-56...
He's been wearing it for almost 8 years now and it still looks great. It's very solid and reasonably priced compared with other jewelers.
James Avery even has some rings with stones in them but we love the one he's got! Hope that helps!
JS