My suggestion is that you start shopping for dentists. I've seen implants and they look just like real teeth. If your implant doesn't, then you have the wrong dentist. You need a dentist that specializes in implants; not every dentist has the experience or knowledge.
I would ask your oral surgeon for some recommendations, but keep in mind that dentists, doctors, lawyers, & all professional people, often refer their clients to professionals that they do business with. It might be better to call the American Dental Association and ask for at least three referrals of dentists in your area that specialize in implant dentistry.
When you go see them, ask to see pictures of their FINISHED work, not just pictures of the procedure itself. You're interested in what your new teeth will look like and the best way to do that is to look at each dentist's work in that area. A good dentist will keep a portfolio of "before and after" pics of his/her work.
Good luck!