J.,
I have no experience with diets. I have never done one. I am really lucky that I have a decent metabolism, am not food driven, and feel uncomfortable if I eat too much. Also, I prefer healthier food.
I have seen my husband do a slew of diets, be miserable while on them, then revert to his old ways. He eventually needed and had good success with a lap band.
best I can offer you is two strategies for weight loss-
1. consider the allen carr book, which is titled something like the weigh to loose weight. it's premises are
a. if you can be mindful of how you feel after you eat unhealthy foods, or too much of any food, you will be less inclined to repeat that mistake.
b. you need a lifestyle change, not a diet. diets don't work.
c. there are no off limit foods, just sometime foods.
d. fresh foods taste good and are good for you.
the other "diet" i have seen work for people is the "eat more weigh less" strategy.
1. you take all the food that you would ordinarily be eating, and split it in half.
2. you preceed and end each meal with a glass of water.
3. you bulk out your food with something healthy and low cal which must be eaten first.
your day might look like this-
6:30 am- 1 glass of water, two mandarin oranges, 1/2 a sausage egg mcmuffin, 1/2 a hasbrown and a 1/2 cup of coffee.
8:30 am. 1 glass of water, three celery sticks, a cup of raw spinach, and as much of the remaining 1/2 breakfast as you can eat.
11:30 am. 1 glass of water, a mcintosh, 1/2 a subway sandwich and 1/2 a bag of chips, and 1/2 a lemonade.
1:30 pm. 1 glass of water, a handful of chocolate dusted almonds and as much of the remaining 1/2 lunch as you can eat,
same concept for dinner.
Ideally, you are disciplined about what you are eating more of. you can stick to it, because there is no deprivation, you are actually eating more. you find yourself eating less and less of the 2nd half of your meals. you re-train your stomach. and you don't have irritability because of hunger.
best to you and yours,
F. B.