How to Help My Child Deal with a Needy Friend

Updated on September 28, 2008
M.C. asks from Irving, TX
5 answers

my son has a friend that i'm noticing is very needy. we do playdates on occasion and they attend the same school. The kid cries at school before my son gets there and makes a breakfast plate for him (the kids usually make their own to learn independence). He seems to only want to play with my son and I am starting to wonder if my son is this kid's only "friend" and my son may be getting sucked in to only play with him. (side note: they knew each other from a previous school, but were in different classes.)I got on the school about breakfast plate thing and was told to please let my son eat it because they didn't want the other kid to cry. I told them if my son didnt want to eat it, he didn't have to. So, I'm also starting to wonder of the school is letting my son be used as a crutch to keep the other kid happy. And i'm NOT okay with that at all. My plan is to talk with the teacher and get her observations and go from there, but i wanted so see if any other parents hav had to deal with this.

i hope i am overanalyzing this

What can I do next?

  • Add yourAnswer own comment
  • Ask your own question Add Question
  • Join the Mamapedia community Mamapedia
  • as inappropriate
  • this with your friends

So What Happened?

Thanks for the great advice moms. I spoke with two teachers at the school and received two different stories. I let the frist teacher (a.m.) know what my concerns were and she said the child has been crying in the mornings and only seems to perk up when my son arrives, and if my son does not want to play with him he cries and she said he also cries when my son plays with other children. I explained that while it is unfortunate that the child is upset, it is not ok to put my son in a position like that & they need to find other ways to help him than making my son his crutch. She said she understood and would talk to the classroom teacher. I spoke with the classroom teacher about the previous conversation and asked her observations. She said that she hasn't noticed that behavior in the room, they separate and do their own thing and play together occasionally. She expressed that she has seen that type of needy relationship in the past with other students and she makes sure to nip it in the bud so they do not develop overly-attached-needy relationships and are able to function once part of the pair moves up or moves on. So it looks like it could be a morning separation issue for the other child and since I've addressed it with the morning teacher, it's going to be watched and managed.

More Answers

Smallavatar-fefd015f3e6a23a79637b7ec8e9ddaa6

B.F.

answers from Dallas on

Hey,
One of my sons had a needy friend like that in kindergarten.
It really is only a problem if your son has a problem with it.
It is his reactions not yours or the school's or the teacher's that counts. It was when I volunteered at school (which I strongly recommend) that I saw that the child was so talkative and attached that he was really bothering my son. We talked about it and he expressed what I had observed. We talked about what he could do about it and it was already late in the year. He made it through that year but I specificly requested that the child never be in the same class together again, and it their senior year and it has never happened. Turns out that child had many mental issues and it would have never worked out for them to be friends but I caution you to speak the truth in love and be an advocate for your son, not an outlet for your fears.
B.

Smallavatar-fefd015f3e6a23a79637b7ec8e9ddaa6

D.S.

answers from Dallas on

THat perfect- speak with the teacher and go from there- getting the other parents involved isnt necessary at this point- its not a violence issue - its something that can be tended to in the classroom- make sure seats are apart and that she doesnt pair them during projects. Its fine to set play time after school- but make it real structutred and set a time for it to end- then I would just make sure that he has play time with other kids from the class as well.I am sure that after speaking with the teacher- she will do whats best for both- Look at it this way- evidentally your son has son great qualitie that this other child admires.

D.

Smallavatar-fefd015f3e6a23a79637b7ec8e9ddaa6

S.T.

answers from Dallas on

My child has a friend who is not quite that needy, but who will tell anyone and everyone that my child is her only friend, and the only one she likes in their class. Meanwhile, my child plays with everyone and has friends both in and out of the class. We have playdates with all the other kids, including this one child. The only real problems we've had with it are when my child goes to the other girl's house for a playdate and then my child plays with the other girl's big brother instead of the other girl. (So much for kids with siblings being soooo much better-adjusted than my only child. Sorry, couldn't resist! ;) ) The other girl's mom has already told me she dreads kindergarten if my child isn't in the same class! Makes me wonder if this is healthy for my child, though again, my child plays with plenty of other kids.

And, after all of this random rambling, that is what I wanted to tell you--as long as your son plays with other children at school and at playdates, he can have independence from that needy child and not feel too smothered. It really is weird that the school is wanting to cater to the needy child that much, possibly at your own child's expense, but as long as you let them know you are watching the situation, maybe you can keep things under control.

Smallavatar-fefd015f3e6a23a79637b7ec8e9ddaa6

B.T.

answers from Dallas on

Erica i ran into this same issue with my son and his cousin.They are 6 weeks apart in age. very different personalitlies.
I kept my niece before they started school.. and they were close Played well together but she was NEEDY...when they entered Kindy i made sure they werent in the same class . and for gym and playgroud times when she would not leave him alone... by not leave him alone she DIDNT want him playing with ANYONE else just her and would throw a horrible fit if he tried to play with anyone else!..i talked to the teachers so they would seperate them and let my son make new friends..
it is so hard ..we want our kids to have friends but sometimes they get ONE needy friend who monoplizes all thier time.
I would definitly talk to teach about it .Let her know all your fears about this one sided friendship . Also the school councillor is a great person to bring into these kinds of situations.It was a sad HARD thing for me..cuz i loved both kids..but YOU know when something is not right for your kiddo..and we have to speak up!!!
My son is in 1st grade now his cousin has made some friends of her own. they are both doing ok...but it helped them by ME breaking her cycle of needyness...sorry if my spelling is horrid!!
good luck
~B. in hurst

Smallavatar-fefd015f3e6a23a79637b7ec8e9ddaa6

G.R.

answers from Dallas on

How old are the boys? How about requesting a conference with the other child's mom to find out what is going on from her and then explain your son's and your position on the matter.

For Updates and Special Promotions
Follow Us

Related Questions

Related Searches