How to Help an 8Th Grade Boy Fit in with the Class??

Updated on November 23, 2010
S.R. asks from Bedford, MA
7 answers

Hi all,

I am teaching 8th grade religious education this year and have many of the same students I had two years ago (when they were 6th graders). Most of the dozen kids are from our town, but two are from surrounding towns. This boy, I'll call him John, is from a wealthy town, and he has a way of talking sometimes that can reflect that fact (unwittingly) in certain inflections of his voice or choice of vocabularly that can make him sound snooty at times. While now he is maturing nicely, he was a bit immature in 6th grade and voiced ideas that sounded rather judgemental and less than loving. These kids have been kept together as a class, so this problem is of years' duration. However, John's very bright, has been homeschooled, has a heart, but is also smaller and skinnier than many of the other boys. And he is gentler and more polite in nature, too, so he doesn't rough house or talk big like the other boys do at times and so may come across as wimpy, too. The other kids tend to be pretty robust in speech and willing to horse around, etc. And they are also gaining their adult sizes, while John is just getting taller, but still skinny and boyish looking for an 8th grader. He also talks softly, and is more hesitant this year with the other kids. We also have three new students (all loud, rambunctious and popular) to our class who are changing its tone, too, making it even more status conscious and somewhat cruel in regards to this social issue.

I don't notice the other kids picking on him, but they don't include him in their conversation either, and when I sit one of the popular kids with him, their pained expression makes it clear they are not happy with the seating arrangement. It's like John's a leper in our class. I've asked him if there's anything I can do. He says "no" and just appears embarrassed. I'm afraid my concern just makes it all the worse for him, but it tears my heart to see this. It's just so blatantly rude and unfair, I really want to turn it around. It's simply not Christian.

The past two weeks he's been very quiet and barely doing any work, which is totally unlike him. So I am concerned this is getting to him, else there might be some problem at home. The Director of Religious Ed wasn't aware of anything when I spoke with her about this, but she may not know either. In the past, I had tried to get another student in the class to befriend him, but no go. Apparently to talk with John is to risk one's own social status. The other kids are not mean, it just seems to be the way things are for whatever reason. But I'd like to change this. I keep racking my brains for some ideas on how to break the ice between him and the other kids so they can see him as the bright, articulate, normal boy that he is. There's so much more to him than this label....

Any ideas on activities, conversations or other methods to break through this unfortunate situation? What kinds of things can I do to maintain an atmosphere that seems welcoming and safe to all and cuts down on the down time conversations and exclusive behaviors?

Thanks and God Bless,
S.

What can I do next?

  • Add yourAnswer own comment
  • Ask your own question Add Question
  • Join the Mamapedia community Mamapedia
  • as inappropriate
  • this with your friends

More Answers

Smallavatar-fefd015f3e6a23a79637b7ec8e9ddaa6

D.H.

answers from Indianapolis on

I have a couple of suggestions......use religion to create a story for this boy........I know there were many in the bible not considered "popular" but they had a place and a mission........make this a lesson on tolerance of others, what is good about them being different, why it's important that we ALL contribute to this earth...............

You might want to make John teachers pet as well........keep him involved.....try to break him out a bit of being quiet by handing out papers, or doing some things to make him interact with the others more....

Is there one skill that John has that he can use to show off? If so is there a way for you to work it so he can show off this talent to the others?

And here's another one that works sometimes..........have each class mate, write something good about all the other classmates.........they have to think, it can't be "he dresses nice"..........but have them put everyones name down, and then fill out something that they see that is good in this person.......a trait in them that will help them in later years.........give them some time to work on this, and make sure to let them know it will be graded and that there must be great thought put into this........this will allow them to kind of look at the other kids in the class and watch for the "good" things that they do...............I read a story where a teacher did this in a freshman class and she then made a list for each student of what was said about the m by the other students.........one of her students died in war, and they ask her to please come to his funeral.........he had that battered peice of paper of what his classmates had said about him in his wallet all those years.........he looked at it every time life took him down......she found out at the funeral, that almost all of the other kids also had their papers that they had put away somewhere to look at or carried it with them as well.........

Good Luck and you're a sweetie for caring so much about these kids......people need to do that more these days with all that is going on.
Take care.

1 mom found this helpful
Smallavatar-fefd015f3e6a23a79637b7ec8e9ddaa6

K.G.

answers from Burlington on

I would not draw ANY attention to him. In fact, the best way to get your group under control would be to have the loudest kids sit next to you! He may be getting bullied which is only amplified if the teacher calls on him, gives him praise at all etc. It is embarrassing to him. You are very well intentioned, and I would suggest discussing your concerns to his parents to see if they have noticed changes in his behavior in school and at home.

S.P.

answers from Los Angeles on

I don't have any particular recommendations as I start writing this but perhaps an idea or two will come to me before I'm ready to send this.

I just wanted to compliment you on how much thought and attention
you are giving to this boy and his situation.

How many kids are in the class?
Here's an idea . . . which may not be appropriate for your class
but I will toss it out anyway.

Let's say there's 16 kids in the class.
Can you break them into teams of four kids each,
and give each group an assignment they will need to work on together,
as a cooperative team.

You could make a list for them of various ways to split up
responsibilities among the members, so that each member's participation is essential for the completion of the assignment.

Rather than letting the kids choose their own teammates,
you consider in advance the various strengths and weaknesses
of the kids, and create teams so that this kid's particular strengths
will be best utilized in making his team effective and successful.
Does that sound too daunting?

Have a different task/area for each team,
so that at the end of the assignment (2 weeks?)
each team can report to the entire class
about what they learned, and all kids will learn something
from the other teams' work.

Good luck.

Smallavatar-fefd015f3e6a23a79637b7ec8e9ddaa6

K.B.

answers from Tulsa on

I don't know how to help now, but in the future he will look back and remember that S. was a woman of God who cared enough to intervene and try to help him. If no one helped him, he would likely feel no one cared enough about him to notice. I am so glad you are his teacher.

Smallavatar-fefd015f3e6a23a79637b7ec8e9ddaa6

N.D.

answers from Springfield on

Hi S.,

You cannot change the way the other students act and you cannot make John more popular but you can express that YOU are uncomfortable with the behaviors going on. You mentioned it is not Christian and you are teaching religious ed, it may be a natural tie between the Bible and modern day problem solving.
I was just at an anti-bullying training (high school teacher) and one of the points they made is that if we do nothing then it is the same as giving permission for the behavior to continue. So, the advice I would give would be to take what the kids think out of the equation. You should model appropriate behavior. Tell them that even when they behave in an ugly manner you are still treating them with respect. If you ask John, he will not ask for help and it may make him more of a target. (The example was that abused spouses never charge their abusers but let it happen)

I may be being overdramatic, but you are the adult and the final line in the sand to tell the popular kids (the ones with social power) that the behavioral expectations are toward those of less power. In or out of your lesson, make sure they know what is or is not okay. John will see that you have his back and the popular kids will at least not be able to say that no one ever told them they couldn't behave in that manner. Be explicit in your expectations and hopefully they will fall in line.

Best of luck, N.

Smallavatar-fefd015f3e6a23a79637b7ec8e9ddaa6

T.F.

answers from Boston on

I know I'm late in responding to this question so I'm not sure if you'll even get it. You already got some helpful ideas but another thought would be that you could gently say something to the parents. Chances are that if they're taking the time to ensure that they're children are attending these classes then they'll be very interested in having their children practice what they preach. You don't have to say that he's being bullied but just gently mention that you see this silent exclusion going on and that it's obvious to everyone and that you can tell it's hurting John.

This exact scenario happened to a group of boys when I was younger (I think it was when they were all in the 6th or 7th grade) and the parents were the ones who made a difference. I know that times are different but they insisted they give this kid a chance at being their friends and he eventually went from outcast to close friend. As a matter of fact, these guys are all still the best of friends today - despite having careers and families of their own.

For Updates and Special Promotions
Follow Us

Related Questions