Oy vey. You sure you want to go down this road?
I separate out the skills that are needed to CAMPAIGN well vs. those needed to ADMINISTER well (which is the job of the President). So as thrilling as it is to watch a great orator or natural campaigner, that's not the main part of the job. I love a great State of the Union speech as much as anyone, but it's one night a year vs. someone who's going to really work and who understands the job the other 364 days.
I think we have to look at the system that gives us this situation now - the big money, the lobbying, the disastrous Citizens United decision, and the reality that ANYONE who rises to the top did so because of compromises made and, sadly, deals done. And that includes members of House/Senate/2 major parties who are super delegates and control the votes.
I compare that to parliamentary systems (Britain, Israel), where lots of parties have to make deals and concessions with each other to get one person elected Prime Minister. It's not perfect either, and definitely "politics makes strange bedfellows" but at least there are some shared goals. And blissfully, the election season is SHORT and then it's done, and they get down to the business of governing. We have a preposterous 2 year campaign season with virtually no one doing any work except actually running for office.
I'd like to see caucuses eliminated, since they utilize very few people and mostly those who have tons of time on their hands - that eliminates working class people who have 1-2 jobs and just can't spend days and days in the caucus process. I'd like to see more open primaries since we only have (essentially) 2 parties - so I'd like to see independents/unenrolled voters being able to vote and to have same-day registration - obviously they have to choose one ballot (Republican or Democrat) and they can't vote twice, but they'd be part of the process.
I'd like to see Election Day NOT be on a stupid Tuesday (a holdover from agrarian societies) but include on-line voting and weekend voting, to accommodate those who work 2 jobs or are disabled, those who observe a Saturday vs. a Sunday Sabbath, and more. I'm sick to death of voter ID laws which are in response to a total non-problem (we have voter apathy in the US, not voter fraud!) and which disenfranchise the elderly (and we had a whole convent of nuns who couldn't vote because they don't drive!) and those who live in cities and don't have a DMV near them. I'd like to see post offices (because they are quasi-government agencies and there's one in every zip code) be places of registration. The GW Bush Justice Dept. did a full investigation and found fewer than 100 "violations", most of which were legit voters who were just in the wrong precinct. Let's face the truth that undocumented workers and criminals with active warrants just aren't racing to the polls to hope they get caught. And let's let those who have paid their debt to society become full and functioning members of society - let them participate.
All that said - I vote for the person who will get the job done that needs to be done. If we have a candidate who doesn't really want the job, just wants to get elected and have a big audience, then we'll have worse gridlock than we have had with a do-nothing Congress. I'm sick to death of the hate speech, and I'm sick to death of conspiracy BS. I'm sick to death of people who don't like Bill Clinton rejecting Hillary Clinton - WHO CARES about their marriage? If she and he worked it out, it's not our business. If Trump is awful to Melania, who cares? (Okay I care - but it's not presidential criteria.) I'm way more worried about "tell it like it is" BS and hate speech. And I care about women and gays and fewer guns and people who really know what the Constitution says instead of what they saw in a commercial, a debate sound bite, or a Facebook meme.
There is no perfect candidate. This is not an acting job for which there will be an Academy Award. This is real life. It's about what the person will do for 4 years, not what they say when they play to the cameras before they have the job. So like any good personnel director, I care a lot less about someone's interviewing skills than their past performance. And I really am not interested in anyone who subscribes to conspiracy theories and has no grip on reality.
It's very easy to pick one faux pas or one disastrous decision and say, "That's a deal breaker". Sometimes it isn't. But I think people usually pick the candidate they want and then throw in all the reasons why the other person is unqualified. And it's hardly ever that simple. I am married to a wonderful if imperfect man who maybe pissed me off 10 or 25 years ago. I can vote for a qualified if imperfect candidate if I think that person has a track record and a grip on reality. I can't vote for someone who's unhinged and who really truly doesn't want to DO the job, just HAVE the job.
I'd like to see all the outrage get focused on the SYSTEM that gave us this situation. I think Bernie Sanders' campaign has told us the average person with little money has been left out of the process (not just voting, but national government). I think Trump's candidacy, on some level, has said people are pissed off at the do-nothing Congress - unfortunately, it has fueled and fertilized the hatred and bigotry against pretty much everyone. On some level, if people understand that LOCAL politics breeds people who can be bought by special interest money and then allowed to rise to the national stage, we'll have a shot at possible reform.