K.A.
We have the Sunshine Kids (Now Diono) 5pt carseat that we use for our 4.5 year old that is close in size to a 6 year old. It's a fantastic seat with high safety ratings. It's also got a narrow base so it fits well in most cars. It's convertible to a booster when the time comes to switch her to that. It attaches using LATCH when being used as a booster so it does not become a projectile in the event of an accident.
I am a bit concerned when you mention leaving your child's coat on in a car seat. Please tell me you do not mean a large winter coat! It is dangerous to buckle a child in their seat with a bulky/puffy coat on. Please read the information in the following link about the safety of leaving a child in their coats while buckled in their seats.
http://carseatsmadeeasy.blogspot.com/2010/12/keeping-warm...