M.T.
I had the same problem with Holloway House and it made it sticky too...I have found the best thing to use for cleaning is the "flax soap"...the brand escapes me right now, but it's the only thing that gives it a great shine and really gets it clean. I will never buy any of the gimmicky cleaners again.
I also have had to mop my floors several times to get the remnants off of the floor...frustrating.
Good luck!
M.