M.W.
Welcome to the PNW from the Midwest! I'm from Michigan, but I chose to live here--although I do miss my family (all back there).
Our daughter is about to turn two. Some of her absolute favorites this past year have been:
* kid sized pots and pans (little mini stainless steel ones)
* larger wooden blocks (loves to make "towers")
* her mini-broom (a little wooden/cornhusk one from Top Ten Toys in Seattle/Greenwood)
* her Raggedy Ann doll--and other dolls for that matter
* her "guys" which are three little hard plastic figurines of Cookie Monster, Ernie, and Elmo (plays with them daily)
It's so fun that she's now getting more into "dramatic" play and enjoying wearing some dress-up clothes (tu tus, fancy hats, any pair of shoes that aren't hers!)...so that would be a recommendation for the future. She has lots of other toys, but we've discovered that she really enjoys the simpler variety. She has just discovered puzzles, and that's what we're going to get her for her second birthday. We really wanted to get her a play kitchen, but they are big, and our house is not!
We did get a wagon for her first birthday, and did not really get to use it until she was about 15-16 months and she absolutely loved it! That's another long-term useful product.
We aren't big on buying from the mass-merchandisers (although the "guys" were a wonderful purchase for us!), and we have had lots of luck shopping at Goodwill in Ballard (not sure if the Bellevue one is as well-stocked), Top Ten Toys (they avoid all the "hyped" toys), and our local consignment stores.
Enjoy this next phase--it has been an absolute joy to watch our little girl just explode with curiosity, social skills, and language this past year!