Have you contacted Dove to see if the product is still available (though it may not be on the shelves locally)?
Indianapolis is a test market for many products, and they come and go.
We were having trouble finding a product recently (dish washing soap), and I sent a message off to the company via their website, they responded with a list of local retailers who should carry it and a phone number to contact in the event we were unsuccessful.
My only other advice would be to see if you can go to a higher-end store, a dermatologist or someone that specialized in skin care to see if they have something similar or a different, similar product you can use.
Good luck!