N.D.
Hi there-
We too are looking to buy a house and have been working with a Realtor since December. Shortly after working with him, we signed a contract with him because he was genuinely a nice guy. However, we are SO glad that we only signed a 90-day contract with him. I can't tell you the heartache that we have faced with this guy.
Fortunately for you, you don't have to deal with contracts...at least those that obligate you to work with a specific agent. That being said, it is always best to find someone that you like and stick with them. As another poster said, they don't make a salary and so rewarding their time and effort is good karma, if nothing else.
As for the situation that you encountered. You might ask what happened to the first guy that took you out. They might work together (and share the commission) or he might have left the industry. Either way, you might feel better if you asked. It does seem kind of funny.
Also, I don't know what your budget is and/or where you are looking but our house is for sale in North Hoffman Estates. We are in one of the top 10 school districts in IL and are nationally ranked. It is Barrington School District and we have a HUGE yard (1/3 of acre). If you are interested in hearing more about our house- feel free to e-mail me. We are considering all reasonable offers.
Good luck.
N.