P.K.
One of my favorite topics. (I seriously considered becoming a lactation specialist) It does lose some quality by storage (freezing), but not much. Deep frozen milk is the best because the cells are harder and less likely to thaw/re-freeze/thaw/re-freeze everytime the freezer door opens up. but, like anything you freeze, meat, chicken, last nights lasagna, it all loses some quality once it's been frozen.
The reason the baby whisperer says what she says is not neccessarily related to the milk losing quality, which we all agree that it does a little, but her point is having more to do with the type of milk your body is making for your baby. Your body (or boobs rather) knows how old your baby is and will make the milk with as much nutritian as your baby needs NOW, plus all the fats, calories, sugars, etc for your baby's needs. Your milk changes depending on your baby's age and it's nutritianal needs. A newborn needs different milk than that of a 4 month old. So, her theory is that if you're freezing your milk for a 4 month old, and giving it to your baby when your baby turns 8 months old, it's not getting the accurate nutritian that your body was meant to create for the baby at 8 months. It's like we're cheating a bit by robbing peter to pay paul in a way, because at 8 months, you'll probably not be nursing or producing as much either because your baby will be eating more table foods and other fluids like water too by then. Here's the up side of what you're doing. Your milk storage now is going to give your baby more time to be on breastmilk prior to going to whole milk and the baby will be less likely to need to go to formula as a suppliment because you're boobs may not be supplying enough then. It also, even frozen 1 year old milk is still better than formula or cows milk. The properties of breastmilk are truely amazing and NOTHING will ever replace it. Did you know that breastmilk can cure pinkeye with just a few squirts? It's true...and it's amazing how healty breastmilk is, even frozen year old milk. So, relax, you're doing wonderfully by freezing it ahead of time. I think the baby whisperers arguement is...if you're not giving your baby the right quality milk at the right stage, why bother? But you could also make the arguement on the other side because it's either freeze it or toss it, and I know I wasn't about to toss that liquid gold!! :)