L....
Another book that might help is "The No Cry Sleep Solution". My mom bought it for me after I told her I just couldn't let my daughter "cry it out". Not everything in there helped but a lot of it did and it gave me some great ideas - some worked and some didn't. All kids are different so it's pretty much trial and error. It takes more time and effort than letting them cry it out but, for me, it was worth it. I do let her fuss a little sometimes and tell myself that she has had tantrums that last longer than 5 minutes so she's ok (My daughter was 2 in November). The bottom line is everything passes....in the beginning, my daughter would only sleep in her swing or if someone was holding her. My sister (who has 2 kids) told me not to worry about it - eventually she'll be too big and it won't be comfortable...that IS what happened!(I hate when she is right!) I used the book to get her to sleep in her crib instead of on someone. Now, she will still wake up at night a few times a week but I just take her in the recliner with me and we sleep/snuggle for a little while and then she's back to bed. I love it since my hubby and I work full time and don't get to see her much during the week PLUS...some day she isn't going to WANT to snuggle with me anymore so I just deal with it. Best of luck to you and do what you feel in your heart is right for you and your family...all kids and families are different.
One other thing and then I'll get off my soap box...here is a piece of information that a good friend of mine passed on to me...you can read a ton of books and get advice from hundreds of people but the bottom line is this....if you make sure your kid is fed, clothed and LOVED, everything else just falls into place. THOSE are the things that are really important!!