R.B.
My daughter had the "flutterbye" one with the birds first, and loved that - but the motor seemed to get loud when the batteries got low... and that drove us crazy (not her though). We then replaced it with the Rainforest one, and she loves it. She's going to be 4 in May and she STILL uses it every night. When she wakes up in the middle of the night and doesn't need us for anything (bathroom, etc.), she'll just pop it on and go back to sleep. It's great! It's nice quiet music and you can shut off all the extras (movement, lights, etc.). We actually just use the music because the bluish light after being asleep was nearly blinding for her... I guess that was one downfall, but we only use if for the music and she does love that.