My daughter turns two next month and we are having the same dillema. She has two older sisters so we have lots of dolls, dress up, stuffed animals, puzzles, all the typical 2 year old girl stuff. I think we have decided to do an outdoor water table for her and I am asking my mom to get her one of those kid sized fold out couches. If you don't have any of the usual girl stuff yet: princess stuff, dolls, dressup clothes and shoes, play food and dishes, easy puzzles, and books were always a hit with my two other girls. Oh My Litlle Pony toys are another idea. I think the Littlest Pet Shop toys are a little old still. I think we waited till Ava was 3 1/2 and got them for her for Chrismas. I think the age on the box says 5 and maybe even older than that.