I'm not sure how far you want to drive. I'm currently taking my 2yr old to a place (home daycare) in Broad Ripple. (52/Winthrop)
She is a very nice lady. Friendly and my son Aidan seems to like her. I will say however, she's a little rough around the edges.(I come from a VERY conservative/religious/clean cut family) but I figure if I can trust her, he comes home w/out cuts and bruises and has a smile...he's in good hands. I don't doubt that she's keeping a good eye on the kids.
She's a single mother, looking to care for a few children in her home. She's VERY flexible in terms of hours, she's reasonably priced as well.
I know she's still accepting kids at this point. Let me know if you're interested in her contact info.