Are My Feelings Justified? or Should I Grow Up?

Updated on August 12, 2008
L.A. asks from Barberton, OH
6 answers

First off let me apologize because this may be long. I need some much needed advice and I really have no one to turn to as it concerns most of my family.

Let me start off with a little childhood background. I am the middle child of 3 kids. Now I know people don't think there is a difference in what order you are born but I believe there is. It seemed to me growing up that I was always independent and made myself into the person I am today. My siblings were handed things to them on a silver platter. For example: my older sibling turned 16 and got a car for her birthday. Never paid for insurance or gas. I turned 16 and had to buy a car from my parents. I also had to have 6 months worth of insurance money before I could drive it. The youngest sibling turned 16 and got a car for his birthday. Not just any car - a new car. He also never paid for insurance or gas. I had to get a job when I turned 15 and contribute to the budget of the house. My siblings never worked until they graduated high school.

So here we are 15 years later and things have come full circle I guess you could say. Now my mother and step-father have long since divorced. We went 3 years without talking to our step-father. I decided that he should remain part of our family. My siblings wanted nothing to do with him for some time. But now I guess since they've learned that they still get everything handed to them on a silver platter everything is just wonderful. My brother recently went back to school and who paid his fees? Mom and step-dad. Anything he wants money for they hand it to him. And it's never a small amount. Just last week he got $500 from my mom just because he needed it.

My sister is even worse. It seems like my step-father works to support her and her family. When she had her 3rd child my step-father gave her a gift of $350. I had my 2nd child 5 months later and he never even came to the hospital. Just recently he took my sisters son to buy a bike because my sister didn't have the money. So he decides to take my daughter to the store to let her pick out a bike. Had I known he wasn't going to purchase it for her that day I never would have allowed it. He told her every week for 2 months that when he could afford it he would buy it. Okay so let him get some extra money. No big deal right? Wrong! I happened to be at my sisters and he shows up with a brand new filter and chemicals for her pool. So where did he all of a sudden get the extra money for that? So I bought the stupid bike myself and never said a word about it.

Now we are up to this weekend. My step-father was supposed to take the older 3 kids school clothes shopping. He was taking my sisters oldest 2 because she is "broke" and he's helping her out and taking my oldest to be fair. So he calls Sunday morning and says he needs to put off taking my oldest because he is going to take 3 of my sisters kids shopping instead of just the 2. So he comes today and he's telling me about how much he spent and it's going to take him awhile to get caught back up so maybe next month he'll be able to take my oldest but he isn't sure yet because my sisters kids need winter coats and thats coming up soon. So while he's giving me the sob story about how "broke" my sister is he tells me about her purchase of a $1200 dog. Confused? I am.

I feel like I am back in my childhood again. Do I have a right to feel like I am a nobody like I felt when I was a kid? It's not just me now though. I have 2 kids being treated the same way. Should I say something or just let it go and suck it up? I really need some advice because I am so tired of feeling the way I do and crying so much.

Thanks ladies and once again sorry this was so long.

What can I do next?

  • Add yourAnswer own comment
  • Ask your own question Add Question
  • Join the Mamapedia community Mamapedia
  • as inappropriate
  • this with your friends

More Answers

Smallavatar-fefd015f3e6a23a79637b7ec8e9ddaa6

C.R.

answers from Cleveland on

L., I completely agree with Rita's advice: sit them down and tell them how they are treating you and now your kids. Advise them that if your children aren't treated equally, then don't call, don't stop by, don't write because you and your kids will not welcome them. Now, about your kids - I'm not sure that I caught their ages, but you need to sit them down and explain to them that love does not equal money, but there's a fairness and a keeping your word thing that's missing in their grandparents and that you (as a family) are not going to put up with it anymore. If the grandparents don't want to change, but your kids experience a loss, adopt some grandparents at a local nursing home - I'm sure that there are TONS who'd welcome some "new" grandkids!

Smallavatar-fefd015f3e6a23a79637b7ec8e9ddaa6

A.H.

answers from Cleveland on

I totally think you have a right to feel the way you do!! You can look at this two ways - one, be proud of yourself for not being 'needy' and show your kids that you work hard to provide for them and dont need help from anyone, etc! two, you can stand up for yourself, let them know that you dont want to be treated this way and that it isnt fair, etc (which its not) and run the risk of them hurting you even more by not changing - in which case, you have taught your kids nothing along the way.

I feel for you, really I do. I am the youngest of 3 girls and my father is the SAME way towards my oldest sister. He pays for the middle child out the wazoo. She is 35 years old and daddy still supports her. He put me through college with no student loans, etc. And hasnt given my oldest sister a dime!! Its pretty sad.

Smallavatar-fefd015f3e6a23a79637b7ec8e9ddaa6

A.S.

answers from Canton on

Hello. Well first off i'm sorry to hear about the way your being treated. I do believe that in some families the middle child gets treated differently. I'm the baby of 3 but we all got the same. To be honest with you my mom helps my brother more than she will help me. Even my oldest brother (when he was still living) she helped him and his family. But i think that you need to say something. If you don't bring it to there attention they will never know. Then you can tell them and it won't change. Either way i feel they should know. I hope things get better for you.

Smallavatar-fefd015f3e6a23a79637b7ec8e9ddaa6

R.H.

answers from Cleveland on

Hello, Its not always the middle child that gets the shaft. It comes in any order. I happen to be the oldest and the middle child gets it all. Me and the middle child haven't ever really gotten a long because I always had her and my youngest sister. Hell, people thought my youngest sister was mine I had her so much. (No resentment torwards my youngest sister. She is metally retarted so I'm happy my parents are there for her) I would sit your parents down and tell them how you feel. They are making your kids feel like nothing too. Don't let them. Tell them if they can't follow through with what they say then not to even bother stopping by. That maybe harsh but what are they doing to your kids??? Good luck to you!!!

Smallavatar-fefd015f3e6a23a79637b7ec8e9ddaa6

E.S.

answers from Cleveland on

My best friend is the second child in a family of four. Her parents paid for her younger brothers' education, bought them cars, has bailed her oldest sister out of so many financial obligations it's ridiculous... my friend, however, gets nothing. And never has. She moved out-of-state and now enjoys a peace that she never knew before.

The worst thing about people who treat others with a lack of respect and consideration is that they'll never admit it. It sounds like you're hoping if you confront your family, especially your step-father, he'll have some sort of break through, apologize, confess a realization that he's treated you and your children abominably, promise to do better, and thus, in the future, you can all be a happy family where things are fair.

But you know this is unlikely to happen. Very unlikely. People who routinely make excuses do not often come clean and suddenly decide they're going to live up to their word. And you've got to set aside any thoughts of how "if he loved you or your children as much..." because that isn't it, either. It's a relationship pattern that was established a long, long time ago - it has nothing to do with who loves who more and everything to do with the way the relationship has been allowed to progress.

You can stop all contact of the sort that has occurred, or you can decide you're going to be more assertive and show your children that "being nice" is not the same as allowing others to take you for granted, get away with disappointing you, etc.

Because it's our family, we are often willing to make lots and lots of exceptions. When you have children, though, you have to think in terms of: Is this the sort of behavior I would want my kids to put up with from their friends? Would I want my children to feel as though this is how friends treat each other? Would I want them to expect this from their future significant others?

For me, the easiest way has been to come up with a saying, or a few sayings, that I can repeat without backing down, and to remember when I approach the subject, I'm not there to argue. People like this will often try to draw you into an argument to prove that your perception is incorrect (and you're already doubting yourself so you don't need that) and they're not as bad as you seem to think.

In this instance, the next time your step-dad says he wants to do something with your children, maybe say: I am trying to raise my children to understand it's important to keep your word. Can I count on you?

Or when your kids see the other kids have things they don't: I am trying to raise my children to be able to be happy for others when good things happen to them, but when you are the source of others' good fortune, it makes it very difficult.

Roll around a few scenarios in your head, remember your children will benefit greatly in the long run, pray if you are a Christian, God doesn't ask us to be doormats. In fact, we are told to "speak the truth in love" and to confront situations like these...

All the best - and many, many kudos to you for trying!

E.

Smallavatar-fefd015f3e6a23a79637b7ec8e9ddaa6

J.G.

answers from Cleveland on

Yes, in some families being the middle child sucks... but you do have parents who are there for their kids no matter what.

I also was the middle child, my sister got to go to band camp every year and when I wanted to join band I was told no way... eventhough I saved up my own $ to by my flute I wasn't aloud to get it and my mom took my $. Now, my brother - got to do everything he wanted... he went to FL with choir and mom paid every penny - when I was in choir we had a trip to Canada and I scraped together ever penny to go & didn't even have any $ to eat for the 4 days we were gone... I ate what my friends didn't.

But it made me see what I didn't want to put my kids through... yes it hurts and yes you ahve a right to be upset. I don't spend much time with my side of the family, but I'm lucky enought to have in-laws that show me what a true family is like.

I don't think it will ever change for you even if you do say anything, but what is it actually going to hurt?? They aren't there for you now, where are they going to go if they don't like what you say??

Sorry, maybe on this one I'm not the best person to take advice from... Good luck - personaly I do feel if it is hurting you, it is hurting your kids... protect them!!!

For Updates and Special Promotions
Follow Us

Related Questions