Has anyone ever taken the Texas Eagle Amtrak train to Chicago?? I may need to get to the Chicago area on semi-short notice and this seemed to be the cheapest way. ($220, vs upwards of $500 on American Airlines). I read the responses to the other Amtrak request (back in early Sept). The responses were mixed, which is what I've heard about Amtrak. Some people love it and other people complain that its sort of scummy. I've also heard that the route makes a big difference. I will be traveling in coach, its a 22 hour ride. One of the responders to the other Amtrak request indicated that coach was full of "lower class people" (not my words there), and they were smoking and getting drunk. This is not a vacation for me, so I'm looking for a quiet trip. I've schlepped back and forth to Chicago twice already in the past three weeks. I need a cheaper alternative to air and car travel (car takes 16 hours, which works out to two days because I can't drive that long without sleeping!).
What do the Mama's think? Also I know American offers Bereavement and Compassion Fares. I wasn't impressed with the Compassion Fare discount, can anyone offer input on Bereavement Fares? Of course, Mom is still hanging in there, but time is short. Does Amtrak offers anything?
Wow, everyone's responses were great, thanks Mamas! I ended up taking Amtrak, it was about a 23 hour ride. It was fairly pleasant. I rode in Coach, upstairs. You don't want to take the lower reserved coach, unless you have mobility issues. Its MUCH better upstairs, and a better view. There were all kinds of people on the train: I met an honest to goodness cowboy, an 82 year old WWII vet who has just published a book, a retired dad who was moving his daughter cross country, and several ladies travelling alone. Admittedly, there were a few people who were rough around the edges, more than you would see if you were travelling by airline. But no one bothered anyone else. I got a little nervous when a gent sat down behind me with a big cooler full of beer, but the 82 year old man sat down next to him and ended up sharing the Gospel with him all night (tee hee) so I think that put a damper on his little binge. Things I strongly suggest you bring: your own pillow, a blanket, shoes you can easily slide on and off, lots of wet wipes, lots of snacks or even meals, an mp3 player or earplugs, and dress in layers. You can bring a cooler, which is nice for us families, but be aware that people can and do bring alcohol on board. I ate dinner in the dining car, it was a bit spendy, but totally worth it for the entertainment value. They fill up each table with four people, so if you are travelling alone, you'll meet some people that way. I had a burger, it was enormous and pretty good. I had a hot dog from the snack car for lunch, which was microwaved, and just OK but not worth the $3.50. As for kids, they would love it, as long as you bring things for them to do and go to the lounge car a lot. The lounge car was a fun place to hang out and watch the miles go by. The Red Hat Society got on in St Louis and pretty much took over the lounge car, but that was OK, they were funny and having an uproarious good time.
When you travel in coach, you choose your own seat, so if someone sits by you and you aren't comfortable there, just get up and move but remember to take the little paper that the conductor gives you that states your destination. the seats are roomy and fairly comfortable, as long as you have your pillow. The actual seats would compare to business class in an airplane, but with first class leg room. Oh and they actually call out for smoke breaks when they know there's a longer stop. So you can hop on and off to stretch your legs or smoke if you're a smoker. There's no smoking on the train itself. Most of the Amtrak employees were nice, but some of the other passengers said they were being hateful. I think as long as you show everyone respect, they're Ok. Keep an open mind regarding the people, as you will meet all kinds of folks.
The Texas Eagle, I found out, runs notoriously late. It is usually between 2 to 6 hours off schedule. Our train was 45 minutes late, which wasn't bad actually. It gets hung up in Fort Worth usually, we left about an hour after schedule.
Overall, I would recommend the train, if you need to get somewhere on semi-short notice, but can spend two days getting there. If you have enough notice to book an airplane ride for the same price or lower, definitely take an airplane, just because its so much faster (and actually more reliable, since this train has a 0% on time rating). If you are just concerned about economics, I think it is cheaper for two people to take the train and upgrade to a roomette sleeper from Ft Worth to Chicago than to drive our minivan and stop overnight in a hotel half way, and it does take less time than driving.
Featured Answers
J.H.
answers from
Dallas
on
Hi K.,
I flew from DFW to Columbus last February when my aunt passed away. American gave me and my husband a great price with the bereavement fare. When I looked online at tickets, they were 700 each, but when I called and talked to them, we both went for 500 total (so 250 each). They were AWESOME, not just with price, but very compassionate, did everything they could, got us on whatever flight we wanted. We just had to call them the day before the flight left to let them know we'd be on it. They were amazing, can't say enough good things about American.
J.
1 mom found this helpful
Report This
More Answers
K.R.
answers from
Dallas
on
I hear its really not bad at all. Train is the only way my father-in-law likes to travel and he takes the Texas Eagle to come see us. The train can be late sometimes though I think they have been more on time lately. I'm sure you will end up with an entertaining story or two but it is safe from everything I have heard.
1 mom found this helpful
Report This
S.S.
answers from
Dallas
on
My mother took this trip this spring just to see what it was like to travel by train. She got on the train in Mineral Wells I think but by driving out to east Texas her fair was a little bit cheaper. She loved it, although she did say that it tended to run a little behind because of having to give way to the freight lines. She had a roomette and said that it was not that comfortable and that she probably could have slept in the just as well. Other than that she was very happy with the experience and was glad that she was able to meet all types of people and chat with them for a while. There is no smoking on the train, or my mother would have never gotten on it. She lost her husband to lung cancer four years ago and is very adamant about not being in public places that allow smoking. I say go for it and talk to Amtrak about the fares and why you are traveling up there, they may be able to help you out. Hope this helps and may God Bless you and your family in this time of need.
1 mom found this helpful
Report This
J.T.
answers from
Dallas
on
22 hours is a long ride on a train. I took my first AmTrack in June from Fort Worth to Oklahoma City. The ride was only 3 1/2 hours long and it went by pretty fast. I traveled coach and there was no smoking. There was a mix of different classes of people -- everyone from retired couples to young teenagers, military guys, moms and kids, etc. The seating was very roomy, not at all like an airplane. You can bring your own food. The one thing that gave me pause was how friendly everyone was. People trying to make small talk and entire groups forming in sections where people yammered on and on. Definately take an Ipod. But other than that the ride was fine. I will do it again.
1 mom found this helpful
Report This
A.
answers from
Dallas
on
Hey K.,
We recently went through the same thing with my mother in law who lived in North Dakota. Northwest offered a very good family emergency fare for us (basically 1/3 price tickets). So if Northwest flies to Chicago, you should check with them. Hope this helps you out. Take care.
A.
1 mom found this helpful
Report This
G.H.
answers from
Dallas
on
i worked for american for 8 years and never quite figured out how they calculated the bereavement fare! in some markets its good, in others its like whats the point.
wish i could give some insight on the train but i have never had that experience..
1 mom found this helpful
Report This
B.S.
answers from
Dallas
on
K.,
My family has taken the train between Dallas and Chicago many times. There is no smoking in the coach car nor in the sleepers. We always get a sleeper which makes the trip much easier since you have a quiet and private compartment as well as a bed. If you can afford the sleeper I think it is worth it especially if you want quiet (meals are included n the price of the sleeper and you have the option of eating in your sleeper for privacy). If you cannot afford a sleeper or one is not available (a roomette would be all one person would need), the coach cars are not really full of people drinking and having a party. It simply gets a little messy with all the items people take out to make it through the night.
The trip is long, but it goes by fairly quickly if you think about it in segments. Once you get on in Dallas you relax for a few hours, spend time in the observation car reading a book (it is quiet there as well), have dinner and go to sleep. Once you wake up, you'll have only a few hours until you are in Chicago and you can spend that time reading at your seat or in the observation car. As long as you have a good book I don't think the trip is bad at all.
People on the train include those who simply love trains, those who don't like to fly (us), people with young kids who want the kids to be able to walk around on the trip (used to be us), and those saving money. We have never had any bad experiences with the people. The trains can run behind schedule since the tracks are not owned by Amtrak and they have to give right of way to freight trains, but generally you arrive within an hour or so of the scheduled time. I wouldn't call the travel luxurious but it is pleasant and the amenities on the train are comparable to a plane, you just spend a bit more time there.
Hope this helps. You might try Southwest Airlines since I believe they fly into Chicago Midway but I'm not 100% sure of that.
1 mom found this helpful
Report This
K.F.
answers from
Dallas
on
My family is in Lombard so I have been making the drive myself often straight-through for the last 16 years on a regular basis. My brother made the trip around 20 years ago by train but of course, his reason was wanting to party on the train, lol. If you want to find out about that particular run I would go down to the Amtrak terminal and talk to porters and other people you would not encounter on the phone that will tell you the truth.
Also, if you are doing this with kids I would suggest shopping around for better air fare. All airlines have bereavement fares with the exception of possibly Southwest because they don't do discounts, however, I know they are compassionate employers so even they may have discounts in the case of bereavement. If you fly odd hours, like 3-4 a.m. flights are cheaper and connecting flights usually also are cheaper and while all of the above would be a pain, it would beat the time for the drive or train.
Twenty-two hours is a long time to be trapped on a train with two active little girls. I feel for you in a big way. My father had open heart surgery 9 years ago, things were dicey but he recovered only to be killed in a car wreck 9 months later. We found out after making the drive that wealthy friends would have put us on a plane :)
1 mom found this helpful
Report This
R.R.
answers from
Seattle
on
Look at Southwest Airlines. I saw some fares between Dallas and Chicago for as low as $258 round trip.
1 mom found this helpful
Report This
A.M.
answers from
Dallas
on
Yes, I've taken the train several times. Recently in July. The trip is a minimum 22 hours. Ours going up was 26 and coming back 30. The most comfy way is to take a bedroom car cause it is more comfort and food is included. As for coach there is no smoking allowed on the train so that is not a problem and the people are all kinds so that is no problem. Take an extra blanket or ways to get warm at night and something to read or a DVD portable player with movies. It is doable take snacks and drinks to cut costs. Prices change daily as to how full the train is. Another option is Airtran--there prices are very reasonable to fly to Chicago. A.
1 mom found this helpful
Report This
B.L.
answers from
Dallas
on
Hi K.
Why don't you just try and go on my website and see if you can get a better rate than what you have found so far for travel. Our website searched all the websites for you so you don't have to and it will give you all your options as it relates to the criteria which you put in. The website is www.langerluxurytravel.com and click on the button book travel. This is one stop shopping you can search for air,car,hotel, whatever your needs are. It has been proven to beat Expedia, Travelocity etc. I have used it myself and found great deals.
Keep the website in your favorites and feel free to use it anytime you want at no cost to you. I think you will find it fasinating!
Enjoy and Have a great trip!