S.M.
When my little boy started sucking his thumb, I had the same thinking as you. I thought that a pacifier would be easy to take away and I didn't want him to be a thumb sucker either. I tried to just keep taking his hands out of his mouth, but I couldn't do that all of the time. When he was sleeping and tired, he would always end up with his thumb in his mouth. I just decided that it wasn't worth the fight. In the end, I actually enjoyed having a kid who was satisfied with his thumb. I never had to worry about losing a pacifier or forgetting to take one with me. He always had his thumbs with him and he could soothe himself to sleep at night instead of me having to go searching for a pacifier in the middle of the night like I did with my first child. I was worried about how long he would suck his thumb, but when my little boy started crawling and eating solid foods and was able to put things like cherrios and fruit puffs in his mouth , he forgot all about his thumbs! He found better things to do with his hands by the time he was 9 or 10 months old. So, I learned that a thumb-sucking kid wasn't such a bad thing. I was also worried about the germs that he would be sticking in his mouth, but he didn't have any more illnesses than my child who used a pacifier! Good luck with whatever you decide!