"he's a good eater and mealtime is so pleasant..." I agree with you to nix the battle. Keep up the brainstorm of ideas; let's see, (a) he'll eat the biter biscuits, when you trained him in the middle of the meal. and how long did that take? ____ (fill in the blank). Let's pretend, for sake of explanation, it took 3 days. Have you tried ONLY 1 other food, trained just like the biter biscuit, for at least 3 days, letting the rest of the food to be fed to him without "strings". And what attention does he get? full eye contact, un-distracted mom? Were you really busy just before the meal preparing it (very distracted)? Perhaps you could feed him for five minutes (until no longer frantic) and then feed yourself or find other distractions so his meal time takes longer... you still feed him, but sporadically and not when he's upset, and before he asks for more, frequently, but not all the time. Be sure to give him the un-distracted time of full eye contact AFTER the meal and not related to eating or cleaning up after the meal... If he's eating well, look at yourself and slowly eliminate any fears about his eating and mealtime in general... I don't think him eating all kinds of food from his hands is developmental, just as long as he does one food, the rest will come, with time. Don't stop trying, just trust that he'll be fine in due time, 'cause he CAN do it... By the way, sounds like your doing a great job...