R.H.
I understand what you mean by the toys in the pinata and goody bags, they are cheesy. One year for my daughter's birthday, instead of candy(her b-day is before Halloween and the last thing the kids needed was more candy) and toys inside the pinata, I used plastic coins instead. I awarded prizes in place of the coins. It kept the fun of breaking the pinata and the kids were able to exchange the coins for a decent prize.