With my first son, I used the candy rewards. But then I found he went dozens of times a day and wanted candy even for a dribble. So, I used the potty present. I bought a small toy and wrapped it up and made a spread sheet on it with 5 boxes. He got a sticker in it each time he peed - 2 stickers for poop. When the boxes were filled, he got to open the present. Then, the next present, we had 10 boxes he had to fill before he got to open it. I think we went up to 30 or 40 boxes before we quit. The presents got a little nicer as he went on. Like the first one was a rubber bug that cost a $1.00. The final one was a note that said he'd get a trip to Chuck E. Cheese. Some other things you could wrap - Hot wheels, coins for the piggy bank, a puzzle, playdough, a DVD, a book, coloring book and crayons (or any other art supply like markers, colored pencils, stickers, stamps, spiral notebooks - these are dirt cheap right now as school supplies are being clearanced). Or you could wrap up "coupons" to go to McDonalds for lunch, the zoo, Chuck E. Cheese, Rainforest Cafe, Build-a-Bear . . . My son loved shaking the present and talking about it, and he has always loved opening gifts, so this really worked for him. I think after the first couple presents, he had to stay dry the entire day to earn the sticker. He'd get a sticker in the morning for being dry all night and a sticker at bedtime for staying dry all day. Good luck!